The Seller Lived Next Door | Sarah Hutchins

Sarah Hutchins had a deal last year where the seller was her next-door neighbor. Dual agency, as-is sale, and a buyer who kept coming back for concessions on a property she already knew better than anybody. Try sleeping on that one.

Key Takeaways

  • Sarah's first dual-agency deal had her next-door neighbor as the seller, and the buyer's side turned out to be the harder half.
  • She laid out the as-is terms with the seller up front, so they were already on the table when the buyer kept coming back for concessions.
  • After moving from Arlington, Massachusetts to Kennett Square, Pennsylvania, she rebuilt her sphere the slow way: community events, her kids' school, and showing up until people knew who she was.
  • In a first meeting she tells clients a deal is a puzzle. Nobody knows where the pieces go yet, and by the end they're all going to fit.
  • She went from managing transactions for a team in 2019 to getting licensed two years later, then went out on her own about a year after that.

She got into real estate sideways. In 2019 she was pregnant with her third kid and going through a divorce at the same time. She wanted something that got her out of the house and used a different part of her brain, so she answered an ad managing transactions for a real estate team. Her background was education. She knew nothing about real estate. Two years later a friend told her she was already doing every step of the job anyway, so she might as well go get licensed.

Then she moved. Arlington, Massachusetts to Kennett Square, Pennsylvania, which wiped out the whole "call your mom, your auntie, your hair lady" list they hand you when you start out. What do you do when the phone book you were told to work doesn't exist yet?

She rebuilt it the slow way. Community events, her kids' school, showing up over and over until people said hey, I know who you are.

We got into what she tells clients when the wheels start wobbling, and real estate might be the most unpredictable industry there is for wheels wobbling. Her line is a puzzle. We don't know where the pieces go yet, and by the end we're going to have it together.

If you know somebody in the middle of a big transition right now, send them this one. You don't have to make a thing out of it. Just say you heard it and thought of them.

In This Episode You'll Learn

- How Sarah navigated her first dual-agency deal when the seller was her next-door neighbor, and why the buyer's side turned out to be the harder half

- Why she laid out the as-is terms with the seller up front, and what that did for her when concession requests started coming in

- The path from managing transactions for a team, to getting licensed, to going out on her own about a year later

- What she actually did to get known in a town where she had no sphere of influence yet

- The puzzle line she uses in a first meeting so clients have a picture in their head before anything goes sideways

- Why "put your phone down and stop looking at Instagram" is a real conversation she has with clients mid-transaction

- What she goes back to when a transition gets heavy, and the beginning-middle-end reminder she keeps in her pocket


Memorable Quotes

> "If you don't have people's trust, like forget it, right? They're not gonna wanna work with you." Sarah Hutchins

> "Sometimes taking the first step is the hardest… your gut doesn't usually lead you astray." Sarah Hutchins

> "Even if it's the wrong way, you're always gonna end up where you need to be in the end. No matter how many twists or how many turns you're gonna take." Sarah Hutchins

> "I almost explained to them as it being a puzzle. We're not sure where all the pieces go now, but at the end we're gonna figure it out and we're gonna have all the pieces put together." Sarah Hutchins

> "That's the game right there. Just tell people to call the damn leads." Drewbie Wilson

Find Sarah

- Instagram: @sarah.hutchins.realtor

- Email: sarah.hutchins@foxroach.com

- Phone: 302-584-4460

Call The Damn Leads


"By sales professionals, for sales professionals — Tales of your wildest sales stories and tactics to succeed in your sales career across various industries."

Join Drewbie Wilson, a sales veteran with over 20 years of experience, as he brings you insider stories, humor, and actionable strategies to excel in your sales journey.

Your weekly dose of:
Wild Sales Stories: Engaging tales of real-life sales adventures.
Proven Tactics: Actionable strategies to boost your sales game.
Humor: A fun and energetic perspective on the world of sales.
Expert Insights: Learn from seasoned professionals in various industries.

Don't miss out on the insights, humor, and strategies that can take your sales career to new heights.

If you'd like to be a guest on the show, leave your contact information and a brief message telling us why your story needs to be heard: https://callthedamnleads.com/pages/podcast

Follow Drewbie: https://www.facebook.com/drewbierides
Follow Call The Damn Leads: https://www.instagram.com/callthedamnleads

More on this: Dennis Mark Interdonato on integrity and double agency in real estate. New here? Start with what Call The Damn Leads is.


Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.


Frequently Asked Questions

How do you handle dual agency when the seller is someone you know?

Sarah Hutchins worked her first dual-agency deal last year, and the seller was her next-door neighbor. She laid it out with the seller from the start: this is an as-is sale, no concessions. The harder half was the buyer. Things came up that they didn't know about going in, and the buyer wanted concessions. So Sarah had to be upfront: "hey, this is the way it is." Drewbie's point for anyone in that seat: know your boundaries, and what's gonna let you sleep at night.

How do you build a sphere of influence after moving to a new town?

When Sarah moved from Arlington, Massachusetts to Kennett Square, Pennsylvania, the usual starter list (call your mom, your auntie, your hair lady) wasn't there. She was moving back to an area she grew up going to, which helped. The rest was showing up. Community events, being active in her kids' school, turning up at different things until she was a face people recognized. What she wanted to hear was "hey, I saw you at the kids school or I know who you are." She still works it that way.

How do you keep real estate clients calm when a deal gets messy?

Sarah starts in the first meeting, buyer or seller, before anything goes sideways. She tells them it's a puzzle: "We're not sure where all the pieces go now, but at the end we're gonna figure it out and we're gonna have all the pieces put together." That gives them a picture to hang onto when it gets weird. And when a client starts spiraling mid-transaction? Sometimes her advice is to stop scrolling Instagram: "Put your phone down for a little bit. Just sit back, I'll take care of it."

How do you get through a big life transition without it taking over?

Sarah's lived one. In 2019 she was pregnant with her third child and going through a divorce, then moved states to be closer to family. Her advice is to go back to whatever grounds you, whether that's therapy, friends, the gym or a run. And remember there's a beginning, middle and end to every transition. Her words: "It's not gonna be forever." For anyone still deciding whether to make the leap: "Sometimes taking the first step is the hardest... your gut doesn't usually lead you astray."